Analysis of the Differences and Causes of Chinese and Japanese History Textbooks

Authors

  • Jiayi Liu
  • Shuhe Lu

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.62051/2r42em09

Keywords:

Sino-Japanese relations; Japanese history textbook; Historical facts; Tampering with history.

Abstract

The publication of Japanese middle school history textbooks caused great controversy between China and Japan, as well as between Japan and East Asian countries. This paper compares the differences in title, cause, content, illustration, and other aspects of Chinese and Japanese history textbooks in describing specific historical events, and finds through the analysis of differences that China is more objective in recording historical facts, while Japan has behaviors such as downplaying, distorting and denying historical facts. On this basis, the study believes that the reason for the difference between Chinese and Japanese history books is that China and Japan have different identities, traditional cultures, and goal pursuits. At the same time, only by proposing measures to narrow the existing differences between China and Japan by urging Japan to face up to and acknowledge relevant history, establish a common historical research organization, and promote cultural exchanges between the two countries can the relations between China and Japan develop healthily and in the long term.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

Wang Chunliang. On the Japanese "History Textbook" incident. Journal of Shandong University of Education, 2004, 6, 22-28.

Liu Haitao, Qin Xia, Li Li et al. Japanese history textbook events and their essence. Journal of Hebei Normal University (education sciences), 2005, 4, 52-55,

Wang Xiaoqiu. On cultural exchange and Sino-Japanese relations. Japan Journal, 2003, 1, 130-138.

Song Shupeng, Yang Yana. On the objectivity of history. Heilongjiang Historical Records, 2009, 22, 75-76.

Bu Ping. Thoughts on the study of Sino-Japanese common history. Studies of the War of Resistance Against Japanese Aggression, 2007, 1, 197-210.

Wu Guangyi. An analysis of the war of aggression in Japanese middle school history textbooks. Japan Journal, 2003, 3, 47-62.

Su Mingfei, Zhang Xiaofei. A review of the problems of Japan's new history textbooks. Comparative Education Research, 2005, 6, 38-41.

Gao Xiaoyan. Analysis of the spirit of Bushido in Japan. Studies of Japan, 2006, 2, 51-56.

Shi Guifang. The writing and analysis of Japanese history textbooks on the Sino-Japanese War. Social Science Journal, 2018, 1, 141-151+209.

Zang Xiuling, Song Xiaoxia. Japan's political culture's influence on foreign policy. Journal of Northeast Asia BBS, 2006, 1, 78-83.

Wang Xiliang. The political rightwing "Reform of Evil" Japanese history textbooks: The post-war Japanese history textbook controversy and its crux. Historical Review, 2020, 2, 101-106.

Bu Zhaohui, Wu Xiangbo. The 11th delegation to the Tang Dynasty and its influence on China and Japan: Based on the theory of historical events and cultural transmission. Open Journal of Historical Studies, 2020, 8, 1.

Downloads

Published

01-04-2024

How to Cite

Liu, J., & Lu, S. (2024). Analysis of the Differences and Causes of Chinese and Japanese History Textbooks. Transactions on Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, 5, 240-245. https://doi.org/10.62051/2r42em09